Judge won't rule on gay marriage ban prior to SCOTUS decisions - FOX 10 News | fox10phoenix.com

Mich. judge won't rule on gay marriage ban prior to Supreme Court decisions

Posted: Updated:
April DeBoer is challenging Michigan's ban on gay marriage in court.  (Credit: Fox 2 News) April DeBoer is challenging Michigan's ban on gay marriage in court. (Credit: Fox 2 News)
  • Mich. judge won't rule on gay marriage ban prior to Supreme Court decisionsMore>>

  • Let It Rip: Should Michigan's same-sex marriage ban be overturned?

    Let It Rip: Should Michigan's same-sex marriage ban be overturned?

    Thursday, February 28 2013 11:46 PM EST2013-03-01 04:46:34 GMT
    A lesbian couple is fighting to overturn Michigan's ban on same-sex marriages.  Attorney Dana Nessel and Gary Glenn from the American Family Association of Michigan discuss.
    A lesbian couple is fighting to overturn Michigan's ban on same-sex marriages.  Soon a federal judge will hear arguments in their lawsuit.  Attorney Dana Nessel and Gary Glenn from the American Family Association of Michigan discuss.
DETROIT (WJBK) -

April DeBoer and her partner, Jayne Rowse, are still hopeful, but still in limbo.  Judge Bernard Friedman stayed a decision on the couple's efforts to overturn the gay marriage ban in Michigan until the U.S. Supreme Court decides two cases currently before the justices there.

"We ultimately do want what's best for our kids, and the second parent adoption, again, has always been what we are after," said Rowse.

DeBoer and Rowse are the parents of three special needs children they adopted, but because of Michigan law, they're not able to jointly adopt them.  Michigan law only allows single or married people to adopt, and Michigan law does not allow gay people to marry.  So the children cannot legally have two parents.

Rowse has adopted four-year-old Nolan and three-year-old Jacob, and DeBoer has adopted three-year-old Ryanne.

The women initially challenged Michigan adoption law, but Judge Friedman urged the women and their attorneys to challenge the ban on gay marriage, so they did.

"Michigan has the worst laws in the country, and this is a pervasively discriminatory policy in Michigan," said attorney Carole Stanyar.  "I think it's going to be overturned."

In court this day, Stanyar argued Michigan's ban on gay marriage violates the Equal Protection Clause in the U.S. Constitution.  The state argued Michigan citizens voted for the ban in 2004, and the women should challenge it in the state legislature.

Judge Friedman said he would wait for the Supreme Court to lead the way.

"Our opinion has always been it's never too soon to have equal rights for Michigan citizens, and we feel very optimistic that eventually that is going to be the case," said attorney Dana Nessel.

Judge Friedman said he expects the Supreme Court to rule on its cases by June, then he would be able to make his decision.  However, Fox 2 legal analyst Charlie Langton said by then it could be too late.

"This judge could very well be bound by the Supreme Court.  Essentially today Judge Friedman punted.  He said let them decide, not me," remarked Langton.  "I thought Judge Friedman had an opportunity to actually change law.  I think there are a lot of arguments to be said that same-sex marriage is constitutional and that same-sex marriage should exist today.  Why?  Because times have changed."

"I understand that the voters decided.  That was the big state argument, but the problem here is that the voters cannot vote on something that is blatantly or could be considered unconstitutional," he added.

  • Amy LangeMore from Amy LangeMore>>

  • Former SMART employee's lawsuit battle drags on after 10 years

    Former SMART employee's lawsuit battle drags on after 10 years

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 11:49 PM EDT2014-08-28 03:49:24 GMT
    The case was originally about workplace discrimination. Now it's dragged on for more than a decade despite the case appearing to be one that the Suburban Mobility Authority for Regional Transportation can't win.
    The case was originally about workplace discrimination. Now it's dragged on for more than a decade despite the case appearing to be one that the Suburban Mobility Authority for Regional Transportation can't win.
  • Family's home hit hard by storms for second time

    Family's home hit hard by storms for second time

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 8:51 PM EDT2014-08-28 00:51:07 GMT
    For Ericka Page, first came the flood, then the gas line break and Tuesday, the massive tree limb that broke off with part of it landing on her house.
    For Ericka Page, first came the flood, then the gas line break and Tuesday, the massive tree limb that broke off with part of it landing on her house.
  • Police investigate connection of Southfield suicide and Detroit homicide

    Police investigate connection of Southfield suicide and Detroit homicide

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 6:26 PM EDT2014-08-27 22:26:24 GMT
    Police have identified a man's body with a gunshot wound to the chest found under an overpass at 9 Mile and Southfield Tuesday afternoon.At about the time Michael Young, 56, was found, Detroit Police were called to his home - on Westmoreland for a welfare check."The Woman had not been seen since Saturday," said Detroit Police Officer Adam Madera. "We received a 911 call for the well being check and Southfield Police Department showed up all at the same time."Inside police found the body of 56...
    Police have identified a man's body with a gunshot wound to the chest found under an overpass at 9 Mile and Southfield Tuesday afternoon.At about the time Michael Young, 56, was found, Detroit Police were called to his home - on Westmoreland for a welfare check."The Woman had not been seen since Saturday," said Detroit Police Officer Adam Madera. "We received a 911 call for the well being check and Southfield Police Department showed up all at the same time."Inside police found the body of 56...
  • Local NewsLocal NewsMore>>

  • Child, 3, hospitalized after falling from second-story window

    Child, 3, hospitalized after falling from second-story window

    Monday, September 1 2014 11:31 PM EDT2014-09-02 03:31:18 GMT
    A 3-year-old child is receiving treatment at St. John hospital after falling from a second-story window in Detroit this weekend.
    A 3-year-old child is receiving treatment at St. John hospital after falling from a second-story window in Detroit this weekend.
  • Boy, 5, thrown from father's dirt bike and run over

    Boy, 5, thrown from father's dirt bike and run over

    Monday, September 1 2014 11:18 PM EDT2014-09-02 03:18:50 GMT
    Residents inside Northport Apartments in Macomb Township say that Sunday afternoon they saw a 27-year-old neighbor riding a dirt bike with his 5-year-old son along busy Garfield Road.Neighbors say they've seen him riding before -- but this time he had his child with him."The first thing that caught my eye was he was riding in his dad's lap," neighbor Tim Hale said. "And they were weaving throughout drainage ditches which are pretty steep." Macomb County sheriffs say the small, orange dirt bik...
    Residents inside Northport Apartments in Macomb Township say that Sunday afternoon they saw a 27-year-old neighbor riding a dirt bike with his 5-year-old son along busy Garfield Road.Neighbors say they've seen him riding before -- but this time he had his child with him."The first thing that caught my eye was he was riding in his dad's lap," neighbor Tim Hale said. "And they were weaving throughout drainage ditches which are pretty steep." Macomb County sheriffs say the small, orange dirt bik...
  • Flooding, power outages from latest round of storms

    Flooding, power outages from latest round of storms

    Monday, September 1 2014 10:14 PM EDT2014-09-02 02:14:26 GMT
    More flooding and power outages are being reported after the latest batch of storms.
    More flooding and power outages are being reported after the latest batch of storms.
Powered by WorldNow

KSAZ-TV & KUTP
511 W. Adams St.
Phoenix, AZ 85003

Phone: (602) 257-1234
Fax: (602) 262-0177

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices