High-Speed Rail: Buyer Beware? - FOX 10 News | fox10phoenix.com

High-Speed Rail

High-Speed Rail: Buyer Beware?

Posted: Updated:

(FOX 11) Much was made of the announcement by California's High-Speed Rail Authority that the top-ranked bidder to build the first 29 miles of track came in under estimates.

The group, a joint venture by Tutor Perini/Zachry/Parsons, bid $985 million, about 100 million less than the next lowest bidder.

But some of the nation's top rail experts say they have concerns for two reasons: one, they say Tutor Perini has a history of cost creeps and two, the group got the lowest technical marks of the five bidders and should have been kicked out of the running.

Critics charge the rail authority deleted its own wording that specified only the top three technical teams would be considered.

"They issued an addendum to this process, and they deleted the part where they said only the top three on technical merit would be considered," says Morris Brown, the founder of the grassroots rail watchdog organization, Derail. "When they eliminated looking at technical merit first, they essentially discarded it as really being a factor."

Brown says: "Even with that low bid, we're not getting electrified rail, we're not getting rail cars and we're also still paying CalTrans a couple hundred million to move Highway 99."

  • FeaturesMore>>

  • Midday Sunday

    LA City Council Member Tom LaBonge

    LA City Council Member Tom LaBonge

    Sunday, August 31 2014 12:00 PM EDT2014-08-31 16:00:21 GMT
    Today's guest is Tom LaBonge, the Los Angeles City Council member representing Council District 4.  Mr. LaBonge is a native Angeleno, born and raised in the Silver Lake District. 
    Today's guest is Tom LaBonge, the Los Angeles City Council member representing Council District 4.  Mr. LaBonge is a native Angeleno, born and raised in the Silver Lake District. 
  • Wednesday's Child

    Julissa Strives For The Award Of A Loving Family

    Julissa Strives For The Award Of A Loving Family

    Thursday, August 28 2014 2:06 PM EDT2014-08-28 18:06:45 GMT
    Just days before this week's Emmy awards show, this week's Wednesday's Child Julissa (1998) got a chance to shine as she walked the red carpet at the Doris Bergman Pre-Emmy Gifting Event.
    Just days before this week's Emmy awards show, this week's Wednesday's Child Julissa (1998) got a chance to shine as she walked the red carpet at the Doris Bergman Pre-Emmy Gifting Event.
  • Midday Sunday with Tony Valdez

    Lisa See: China Dolls

    Lisa See: China Dolls

    Sunday, August 24 2014 12:00 PM EDT2014-08-24 16:00:21 GMT
    Lisa See's new book 'China Dolls' continues her tradition of writing novels that are a touchstone for the Chinese-American experience. The Los Angeles author's ninth book focuses on the experiences of three young Asian women working in San Francisco night club called The Forbidden City before the beginning of World War II.
    Lisa See's new book 'China Dolls' continues her tradition of writing novels that are a touchstone for the Chinese-American experience. The Los Angeles author's ninth book focuses on the experiences of three young Asian women working in San Francisco night club called The Forbidden City before the beginning of World War II.
  • Studio 11 LA FeaturesMore>>

  • Porscha-Diva on Wheels Needs a FURever home!

    Porscha-Diva on Wheels Needs a FURever home!

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 6:41 PM EDT2014-09-02 22:41:50 GMT
    Joining us on Studio 1 LA today are founders of Saving K9 Lives, Jasmin Gabay, and her husband Bobby Kimball. We also have Porscha-Diva, who is in need of a forever home.Porscha was dumped at East Valley shelter because her owners could no longer take care of her.
    Joining us on Studio 1 LA today are the founders of Saving K9 Lives, Jasmin Gabay, and her husband Bobby Kimball. We also have Porscha-Diva, who is in need of a forever home.Porscha was dumped at East Valley shelter because her owners could no longer take care of her.
  • California High-Speed RailMore>>

  • California High Speed Rail

    Feds Greenlight Initial Construction

    Feds Greenlight Initial Construction

    Thursday, June 13 2013 10:05 PM EDT2013-06-14 02:05:22 GMT
    The Surface Transportation Board gave the nod today for California High-Speed Rail Authority to start building the initial 65 miles of the bullet train project from Merced to Fresno.
    The Surface Transportation Board gave the nod today for California High-Speed Rail Authority to start building the initial 65 miles of the bullet train project from Merced to Fresno.
  • California High-Speed Rail

    High-Speed Rail: Board Chooses Lowest Bidder

    High-Speed Rail: Board Chooses Lowest Bidder

    Friday, June 7 2013 12:15 AM EDT2013-06-07 04:15:43 GMT
    California's High-Speed Rail Authority is moving forward on finalizing a $985 million dollar contract to build the first 29 miles of track from Madera to Fresno.
    California's High-Speed Rail Authority is moving forward on finalizing a $985 million dollar contract to build the first 29 miles of track from Madera to Fresno.
  • Saving The California Dream

    Californians Back Brown’s Budget Plans

    Californians Back Brown’s Budget Plans

    Friday, May 31 2013 9:21 PM EDT2013-06-01 01:21:25 GMT
    A new poll released this week by the Public Policy Institute of California finds most Californians favor Brown's budget, which pays down debt, includes increases in education spending and puts money away for a rainy day.
    A new poll released this week by the Public Policy Institute of California finds most Californians favor Brown's budget, which pays down debt, includes increases in education spending and puts money away for a rainy day.
Powered by WorldNow

KSAZ-TV & KUTP
511 W. Adams St.
Phoenix, AZ 85003

Phone: (602) 257-1234
Fax: (602) 262-0177

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices