DEBATE: Prisoner of War vs. Negotiating with Terrorists - FOX 10 News | fox10phoenix.com

DEBATE: Prisoner of War vs. Negotiating with Terrorists

Posted: Updated:

The Taliban's release of Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl has sparked an interesting national debate: Was he a prisoner of war or did the United States just negotiate with terrorists?

Members of Congress are upset that they weren't consulted on the deal beforehand, but the controversial negotiations had apparently been going on for a while.

The secret talks originally centered around some kind of broad peace accord with the Taliban in Afghanistan, with the Emir of Qatar acting as a go-between; however, in the last few months, it became a straight prisoner swap.

How a person views the exchange depends a great deal on how they view America's longest war, but to his family, Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl is a hero -- period.

MORE: Free soldier's parents say they're proud of son

To the White House, Bergdahl is a 5-year prisoner of war.

"The United States does not leave our men and women in uniform behind," Jay Carney said.

To some in Congress, Bergdahl is a pawn in the war on terror, with some lawmakers openly criticizing the decision.

"This is really not a good idea to open up and end a chapter of American history where we don't negotiate with terrorists," Rep. Mike Rogers said.

After wandering away from his Afghan Army unit 5 years ago, Berdahl was captured by the Taliban and held in near-solitary confinement until his release this past weekend. The U.S. struck a deal that exchanged his freedom for the release of 5 Taliban militants held in Guantanamo Bay who must now stay in Qatar for at least a year.

Sen. John McCain, himself a prisoner of war, said the U.S. may have set a dangerous precedent with the agreement.

"I'm very concerned about these peoples' ability to become instant heroes to the Taliban and Al-Qaeda and be able to -- as others have -- assume positions of leadership which puts Americans' lives in danger," he said.

Retired foreign service officer Bill Davnie worked in Afghanistan and Iraq during the surge.

"This is not John McCain climbing on a plane with other PoWs," he said. "You're often dealing with people you don't like very much, but they get things done."

Unlike previous wars, Davnie says the battle lines are ambiguous, the tactics are asymmetrical, and enemies -- like the Taliban -- are both combatants and terrorists.

"We are fighting them in Afghanistan as a war," Davnie said. "I think this is a prisoner of war situation and we work to get prisoners of war returned."

As for Bergdahl, he is recuperating at a hospital in Germany and is still struggling to speak English. He may have difficulty defining himself even as others try to do it for him.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • 50 favorite photos from the Minnesota State Fair

    50 favorite photos from the Minnesota State Fair

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 8:26 AM EDT2014-09-02 12:26:10 GMT
    MNFFA Association visits the Fox 9 booth with a Miracle of BirthMNFFA Association visits the Fox 9 booth with a Miracle of Birth
    The Great Minnesota Get-Together is back with its hottest starting day in 20 years, 28 new foods and thousands of memories to be captured in photographs.
    The Great Minnesota Get-Together is back with its hottest starting day in 20 years, 28 new foods and thousands of memories to be captured in photographs.
  • Search for Ty Hoffman called off after bank robbery in Blaine, Minn.

    Search for Ty Hoffman called off after bank robbery in Blaine, Minn.

    Monday, September 1 2014 9:11 PM EDT2014-09-02 01:11:43 GMT
    Ramsey County sheriff's officials said the search for Ty Hoffman has "heated up" after a suspect in the robbery at TCF Bank in Blaine appeared to match his description on Sunday.
    Ramsey County sheriff's officials said the search for Ty Hoffman has "heated up" after a suspect in the robbery at TCF Bank in Blaine appeared to match his description on Sunday.
  • Happy 15th anniversary, Fox 9 Morning News!

    Happy 15th anniversary, Fox 9 Morning News!

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 9:38 AM EDT2014-09-02 13:38:48 GMT
    The Fox 9 Morning News is celebrating 15 years of history, 15 years of bloopers and 15 years of bringing you what you love.
    The Fox 9 Morning News is celebrating 15 years of history, 15 years of bloopers and 15 years of bringing you what you love.
Widgets Magazine
Powered by WorldNow

KSAZ-TV & KUTP
511 W. Adams St.
Phoenix, AZ 85003

Phone: (602) 257-1234
Fax: (602) 262-0177

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices