Arizona woman wanted in cold-case murder of her child detained in Mexico, U.S. Marshals say

Published October 19, 2026 11:27 AM MST

An Arizona fugitive on the run for over a decade has been detained in Mexico in connection with the murder of her child, authorities said.

What we know:

On Nov. 30, 1998, human bone fragments were found by a hunter in a deserted area in Mobile, Arizona. The U.S. Marshals Service says the remains were unidentified for nearly two decades until August 2014, when a forensic DNA analysis matched the bone fragments to 3-year-old Crystal Reyes.

"It was a horrible case, very tragic," Justin Price of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, who was a former writer with the Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting, when he reported on the death. "It was visceral, it was dark stuff. I lived in it for a long time and even after the story published, knowing that one of the two people police believed was responsible for her death was still out there sort of stuck with me."

Price says he first came across Crystal's cold case when working the breaking news desk. He wrote up a story and then received an anonymous call from someone saying there was a lot to the case. That led Price to dig deeper and uncover the tragic details of Crystal's short life, and the twisted web of crime tied to her mother.

Dig deeper:

Authorities say Anna Marlene Somoza gave birth to Reyes in 1993 in Nogales, Mexico. The birth was undocumented. 

Anna Marlene Somoza

That year, she became a confidential informant, connecting with her boyfriend, Avelino Tamala, who was a narcotics detective for Maricopa County. Records show he eventually lost his job due to their relationship. Shortly after, Somoza took the child and went to Ahwatukee to live with her boyfriend, Avelino Tamala, who is not the girl's father.

Avelino Tamala

This is where the child was allegedly subjected to severe abuse, authorities say.

"Behind closed doors, the young child was subjected to severe physical abuse, ultimately being confined to a small dog kennel. Throughout Crystal’s brutally-short-lived life, Somoza and Tamala repeatedly tortured, starved, and abused Crystal as an infant and young girl," the U.S. Marshals Service said. "Reports indicate that Somoza and Tamala would leave Crystal bound by her hands and feet, gagged in a small dog crate for weeks at a time. The abuse escalated fatally on January 30, 1997, when the child was bound, suffocated with a taped towel, and left to die inside a sealed cardboard box."

Price said during his research, he spent countless hours poring over police reports on the case. He says he read many firsthand accounts about Crystal's beauty and how highly those who knew her thought of the little girl who was just starting to develop a personality and a future. A future reportedly taken away by the very people who should've been caring for her and raising her.

"Keeping her locked up in a dog kennel. There were days that she would be covered in her own excrement, and they would wash her down with a hose," Price said. "To go from this, like life of law enforcement for Tamala in particular, to find himself in such a place that he would feel like he could harm a little girl in such gruesome ways."

Timeline:

Investigators say Somoza has a criminal history dating back to the 80s related to drug trafficking. In 1999, Somoza and Tamala were arrested for alleged drug and weapons offenses. Following their arrests, the U.S. Marshals Service says DNA was collected and a forensic analysis of the bone fragments "could not eliminate Somoza as the maternal source."

While Somoza and Crystal's father met during her incarceration, the two reportedly entered into a romantic relationship after Somoza was released from prison. The father knew about the pregnancy, according to Price's reporting, but the two split before Crystal was born, and he told detectives he had no knowledge of her birth or death. 

"Investigators lacked a DNA profile from Crystal’s biological father. As a result, the case went cold while Somoza served an eight-year federal prison sentence. Somoza was released from prison in 2008 and deported to Mexico," the U.S. Marshals Service said.

The father was reportedly was not contacted in 1998, but was found and interviewed by detectives in August 2014. His DNA was also collected and analyzed, leading investigators to be able to identify the bone fragments as Reyes. He also testified at Tamala's trial.

"This breakthrough, along with other evidence gathered throughout the investigation, provided sufficient grounds for prosecutors to charge Somoza and Tamala for the first-degree murder of Crystal in December 2014," the U.S. Marshals Service said.

On Dec. 12, 2014, a grand jury indicted Somoza and Tamala for first-degree murder. Arrest warrants were issued and Tamala was taken into custody. Somoza was believed to be in Mexico.

Two years later, Tamala was found guilty of Reyes' murder and sentenced to life in prison.

Fugitive Caught:

On Oct. 18, 2026, Somoza, 60, was detained in Xochitepec, Mexico. Authorities say her close connections with cartels aided in her ability to avoid being captured by law enforcement.

"We didn't give up the hunt," Van Bayless, a United States Marshal for the District of Arizona—Phoenix said. "We continued working it, we have folks that work on both the north and the south of the border that work with Mexican officials, and they kept working this, and unfortunately we believe that she was intentionally being deceptive, moving around, because she knew that this was looming over her."

What they're saying:

"This disturbing case can finally move forward with justice for Crystal," said U.S. Marshal Van Bayless for the District of Arizona. "[The] Phoenix Police Department and Maricopa County Attorney’s Office showed their unrelenting desire to get Somoza into court and prison for her atrocities to an innocent beautiful little girl. This case became our priority with our partners, both north and south of the border, who we are grateful for, and now she will be coming back and held accountable."

"It does take something out of an individual, and you pay a price for it, just carrying that burden, so cases like this, when you're actually able to apprehend a person, get them back, see them tried, see them found guilty, it gives you a measure of closure," Bayless said. 

What's next:

Authorities say they will continue their efforts to secure Somoza's return to Arizona to face pending charges. There is no timeline for the extradition. 

The Source: Information for this story was gathered from an Oct. 18, 2026, news release by the U.S. Marshals Service; Justin Price of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and former writer with the Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting; Van Bayless, United States Marshal for the District of Arizona—Phoenix; and FOX 10 reporter Nicole Krasean.

Crime and Public SafetyPhoenixWorldNews