Review: ‘The Lost City’ almost strikes gold at SXSW
Austin, TX - Sandra Bullock made a telling quip at the SXSW premiere of her new comedy, "The Lost City." She thanked the Paramount reps in the audience for supporting the film before adding, "You didn’t trust us completely, but you trusted us." The joke helped snapped into focus a feeling of compromise that hangs over the film, which was originally meant to be called "The Lost City of D" before the title was softened to the more generic "The Lost City" — perhaps the first sign of trouble in paradise.
Indeed, it’s not hard to imagine a version of this story that’s a raunchier, more subversive R-rated comedy instead of a generically palatable PG-13 rated one. As is, it feels more like it should’ve been called "The Lost City of ADR," given the copious amounts of additional dialogue replacement that fill up just about every moment of silence with an inelegant joke or clunky transition. (That’s often a sign of a movie that was rejiggered in post to satisfy anxious studio execs or unhappy focus groups.)
WATCH: Learn more about ADR in the documentary "Making Waves," streaming free on Tubi
Still, given those parameters, it’s a wonder that the film emerges as the relatively enjoyable romp it is — compromises and all. "The Lost City" is a good-not-great adventure romance in the vein of "Romancing The Stone," and in an era of Hollywood in which those kinds of movies are few and far between, perhaps we’re just lucky to have this one at all.
About ‘The Lost City’: ‘Romancing the Stone’ for the 21st century
Brad Pitt, Sandra Bullock and Channing Tatum in "The Lost City" (Photo: Paramount Pictures)
"The Lost City of D" is at least still the in-universe name of the new book from lonely romance novelist Loretta Sage (Bullock), who reluctantly agrees to promote it alongside her lunkheaded cover model Alan (Channing Tatum) — better known as her dashing protagonist Dash McMahon. Loretta is frustrated that Alan’s abs keeping stealing the spotlight, while Alan is frustrated that he keeps putting his foot in his mouth in front of Loretta when all he wants to do is convey how much he respects and admires her.
So when Loretta is kidnapped by an eccentric billionaire (Daniel Radcliffe) who wants to enlist her to help find the actual Lost City of D, Alan spies a prime opportunity to prove his mettle and rescue her — or at least to recruit a highly trained black ops agent played by Brad Pitt to take him along on the rescue mission.
RELATED: At the SXSW Film Festival, Nicolas Cage watches Nicolas Cage play Nicolas Cage
Pitt’s involvement is another thing that feels like it was meant to play as a big surprise cameo, but has now been heavily featured in the film’s marketing campaign. Thankfully, there’s still plenty of subversive fun to be had with the way the film deploys him as a foil for the burgeoning connection between Loretta and Alan.
Pitt’s Jack Trainer is exactly the sort of ruggedly confident hero Alan wishes he was in real life. And when circumstances conspire to leave Alan and Loretta stranded alone, it quickly becomes clear just how little their respective experiences as a writer and model have prepared them to survive in the jungle.
See ‘The Lost City’ for: Its charming central duo
Sandra Bullock and Channing Tatum star in Paramount Pictures' "THE LOST CITY."
Of course, the joy of adventure romances like "Romancing the Stone" and "The African Queen" is feeling stuck right alongside the leads as the adrenaline of their adventure fuels the throes of passion. And in its best moments "The Lost City" locks into that tone, as Bullock and Tatum banter about the ethics of taking out a baddie or almost lose their lunch over leeches.
This is as good a showcase for Bullock’s physical comedy skills as she’s ever had. Whether struggling to perch on a stool in a purple sequined jumpsuit or trying to slither out of a hammock, she’s got a silent film star’s knack for telegraphing a joke across her face as she wildly contorts her body — which is why it’s so annoying that the film keeps circling back to those generic ADR-ed one-liners, as if afraid the audience will lose interest the second someone isn’t speaking.
RELATED: Revisit the 5 coziest moments from ‘While You Were Sleeping’
Tatum’s the real revelation, however, returning to the himbo comedic roots that made him such a winning romantic lead in his breakout turn in the 2006 teen comedy, "She’s The Man." To varying degrees, most of Tatum’s roles since then have taken advantage of the contrast between his hunky good lucks and his inherent puppy dog charm. But these two rom-coms in particular dial up the comedic softness in a way that’s incredibly endearing.
In place of a classic oil-and-water screwball comedy dynamic, Alan is hopelessly in love with closed-off Loretta, no matter how coldly she treats him — a unique kind of romantic fantasy of its own.
Sandra Bullock and Daniel Radcliffe star in Paramount Pictures' "THE LOST CITY."
Yet despite Bullock and Tatum’s considerable charms, "The Lost City" is bloated with ideas instead of streamlined with rom-com passion, as cutaways to needless subplots keep deflating the romantic tension.
It’s hard to blame the cast — Radcliffe is a hoot as an arch baddie and Da'Vine Joy Randolph and Patti Harrison (playing two members of Loretta's team) remain two of the funniest comedic actors working today. But more isn't always more when it comes to zeroing in on a story that needed more heart and way less plot. "The Lost City" too often swerves towards the generic catch-all appeal of a big action comedy instead of zeroing in on the rom-com stuff it does best.
It adds up to a comedic effort that’s not bad, exactly. It’s just that when a movie is this close to being great, you wish it could’ve kept searching for treasure instead of settling for staying back at base camp.
Reviewed out of the SXSW Film Festival. Opens in theaters March 25. Rated PG-13. 112 minutes. Dir: Aaron Nee and Adam Nee. Featuring: Sandra Bullock, Channing Tatum, Daniel Radcliffe, Da'Vine Joy Randolph, Patti Harrison, Oscar Nuñez.
Sandra Bullock, right, and Da'Vine Joy Randolph star in Paramount Pictures' "THE LOST CITY."
About the writer: Caroline Siede is a film and TV critic in Chicago, where the cold never bothers her anyway. A member of the Chicago Film Critics Association, she lovingly dissects the romantic comedy genre one film at a time in her ongoing column When Romance Met Comedy at The A.V. Club. She also co-hosts the movie podcast, Role Calling, and shares her pop culture opinions on Twitter (@carolinesiede).
More Sandra Bullock, streaming (for free!) on Tubi
While You Were Sleeping (1995): "While You Were Sleeping" is an underrated holiday classic — a Christmas rom-com with festive cheer but one that doesn’t lean into the holiday spirit so much that it becomes full-on treacly. Sure, the 1995 romance has its weird side. It centers on Lucy (Sandra Bullock), a fare token collector from Chicago who saves her handsome crush when he falls onto the tracks and then inadvertently winds up pretending to be his fiancée when he falls into a coma. But "While You Were Sleeping" is also honest about the pain of loneliness and the difficulty of going through life without family (or found family) by your side. Rated PG. 103 minutes. Dir: Jon Turteltaub. Also featuring Bill Pullman, Peter Gallagher, Peter Boyle, Glynis Johns, Jack Warden.
The Heat (2013): Katie Dippold is a screenwriter to watch. Not only did she pen several of the most memorable episodes of "Parks and Recreation" and the winning Melissa McCarthy caper "Spy," she’s also the woman behind the top-tier buddy cop action vehicle, "The Heat," starring McCarthy and Sandra "Sandy B." Bullock. And she’s just getting started! But even if "The Heat" were Dippold’s only flick, she’d still be responsible for what is without a doubt the funniest tracheotomy in the history of cinema, and that should be celebrated — just like the rest of the movie. Rated R. 116 minutes. Dir: Paul Feig. Also featuring: Marlon Wayans, Michael Rapaport.
About Tubi: Tubi has more than 35,000 movies and television series from over 250 content partners, including every major studio, in addition to the largest offering of free live local and national news channels in streaming. The platform gives fans of entertainment, news and sports an easy way to discover new content that is available completely free.
Tubi is available on Android and iOS mobile devices, Amazon Echo Show, Google Nest Hub Max, Comcast Xfinity X1, Cox Contour, and on OTT devices such as Amazon Fire TV, Vizio TVs, Sony TVs, Samsung TVs, Roku, Apple TV, Chromecast, Android TV, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X | S, and soon on Hisense TVs globally. Consumers can also watch Tubi content on the web at http://www.tubi.tv/.
Tubi and this television station are both owned by the FOX Corporation.