Death penalty sought for suspect accused of stabbing Phoenix teen 27 times if convicted

Published November 17, 2026 6:18 PM MST

The Maricopa County Attorney's Office is intending to seek the death penalty against the man accused of brutally killing a Phoenix woman, if he gets convicted of first-degree murder.

The backstory:

Ring camera showed Yessenia Norman, 18, leaving a transitional facility that was contracted with the Arizona Department of Child Safety, where she had been living, on the night of Jan. 15, 2026. Her friends said she was meeting someone she met through a dating app.

Norman was reported missing on Jan. 19, and on Jan. 28, she was found dead in a Tolleson apartment.

Phoenix Police investigators said the teen was stabbed 27 times, and her body mutilated, which was covered in blankets and towels. 

On Feb. 6, Randal Santillan, 27, was arrested in Biloxi on first-degree murder and kidnapping charges in connection with Norman's death. Police said Santillan left Tolleson immediately, as license plate readers tracked his vehicle over the following days in New Mexico, Texas, Illinois, Missouri, and Mississippi. He was extradited back to Arizona, and indicted that month on one count of first-degree murder and kidnapping. 

Dig deeper:

"Both the suspect and victim’s cell phone devices are located in the area of Yessenia’s residence the night she disappeared," a previous FOX 10 report said. 

"While going through digital evidence, detectives discovered child sexual abuse material on Basilio Santillan’s phone. In September, a grand jury indicted him on ten counts of Sexual Exploitation of a Minor, a Class Two Felony and Dangerous Crime Against Children," MCAO said on Nov. 17. 

According to court records, Santillan and his ex-wife were the tenants of the apartment unit where Norman was found, but Santillan's ex had left him the previous December.

Intent to Seek Death Penalty:

On Nov. 13, MCAO filed a notice of intent to seek the penalty against Santillan if he is convicted for her murder. According to court documents, the state alleges Santillan was previously convicted of serious offenses, including the current indictment of kidnapping and a separate case involving sexual exploitation of a minor.

Prosecutors allege Santillan committed these in an "especially heinous, cruel or depraved manner," saying he inflicted violence that was "beyond what was necessary to kill the victim" and conflicted to, knowing the victim had a fatal injury and/or was already dead, the document said. 

To prove these, the state will rely on testimony from a medical examiner and a blood spatter expert with MCAO during the guilt or aggravation phases.   

Prosecutors also intend to call the same witnesses and use the same evidence in a previous notice disclosed on March 18.

What's next:

Santillan is being held on a $1 million cash bond for Norman's murder, along with a $100,000 secured bond for the child sexual abuse material case. 

The Source: Information in this report was gathered from the State's Notice of Intent to Seek the Death Penalty and Notice of Aggravating Circumstances and Witnesses filed in the Superior Court of the State of Arizona in and for the County of Maricopa; Rachel H. Mitchell, Maricopa County Attorney; James H. Baumann, Deputy County Attorney; and previous FOX 10 reports.

Crime and Public SafetyPhoenixNews