Test on voting machine conducted as GOP seeks to postpone Maricopa County election certification

The Arizona Republican Party is pressuring county officials statewide to delay certifying their election results despite no evidence of legitimate questions about the vote count that shows Democratic President-elect Joe Biden won the state.

The GOP also is seeking a court order to postpone the certification in Maricopa County — the state’s largest by population — that’s expected Thursday or Friday before a Nov. 23 deadline.

In northwestern Arizona, Mohave County officials postponed their certification until Nov. 23, while other counties press ahead.

"The party is pushing for not only the county supervisors but everyone responsible for certifying and canvassing the election to make sure that all questions are answered so that voters will have confidence in the results of the election," said Zach Henry, a spokesman for the Arizona Republican Party.

The party has filed a legal challenge seeking a hand-count of a sampling of ballots in Maricopa County and a court order prohibiting it from certifying results until the case is decided.

"This case is about delay — not the adjudication of good faith claims," lawyers for Democratic Secretary of State Katie Hobbs said in a court filing.

MORE: 2020 Election coverage, results

Jack Wilenchik, a lawyer representing the GOP, said at a court hearing Wednesday that the lawsuit’s purpose is to determine whether voting machines have been hacked.

"It’s about making sure there is no error, making sure there is no fraud," Wilenchik said.

Biden won Arizona by more than 10,000 votes, and Maricopa County put him over the top. The county performed a hand-count of some ballots the weekend after the election, which showed its machine counts were 100% accurate. The same was found Wednesday during routine post-election accuracy tests on the counting machines.

Despite challenges to vote counts nationwide from Trump’s campaign and his allies, there is no evidence of widespread fraud in the 2020 election. The issues they have pointed to are typical in every election: problems with signatures, secrecy envelopes and postal marks on mail-in ballots, as well as the potential for a small number of ballots miscast or lost. With Biden leading Trump by wide margins in key battleground states, none of those issues would have any impact on the outcome of the election.

Hobbs, who oversees Arizona’s elections, said Wednesday that she and her family have been threatened with violence.

Hobbs spokesperson Sophia Solis said a threat posted on the Parler social networking site said, "Let’s burn her house down and kill her family and teach these fraudsters a lesson."

Personal information about Hobbs, including her home address, also was posted on Parler, Solis said. A small but vocal faction of conservatives have taken to the lesser-known site because it does not moderate content posted by users as closely as mainstream tech companies like Facebook, YouTube or Twitter.

Hobbs criticized Republicans from President Donald Trump to Gov. Doug Ducey for failing to halt "disinformation."

"It is well past time that they stop. Their words and actions have consequences," Hobbs said in a statement. "Now, I am calling on other leaders in this state, including the governor whose deafening silence has contributed to the growing unrest, to stand up for the truth."

RELATED: Grassroots group seeks to recall Arizona Governor Doug Ducey from office

Ducey said he believed Arizona’s election systems are among the best in the nation but would wait until any court challenges play out before agreeing that Biden won Arizona. But he said threats won’t be tolerated and state police were ordered to protect Hobbs.

"That’s unacceptable, completely unacceptable, and I denounce any threats of violence against anyone in elective office or any Arizonan or American," Ducey told reporters Wednesday. "That’s different than a court challenge. A court challenge will play itself out, but it’s completely unacceptable, any threats of violence."

Arizona’s changing demographics helped Biden win its 11 electoral votes, becoming only the second Democratic presidential candidate since 1948 to claim victory in the longtime Republican stronghold. Mark Kelly also captured the state’s second U.S. Senate seat for Democrats, though Republicans maintained control of the Legislature.

The GOP’s lawsuit focuses on an audit of a sampling of ballots that is required to test the accuracy of tabulated results.

Maricopa County has already completed the audit and said no discrepancies were found.

The GOP wants the sample measured on a precinct level, rather than the audit that was conducted of new vote centers, which let people vote anywhere in the county.

Clint Hickman, a Republican who chairs the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, said in a letter to voters Tuesday that there was no evidence of fraud, misconduct or malfunction.

"It is time to dial back the rhetoric, rumors, and false claims," Hickman wrote.

When postponing Mohave County’s certification, members of the Board of Supervisors cited what they said was uncertainty about the fate of election challenges nationwide. But they expressed confidence in county’s election process.

"There are lawsuits all over the place on everything, and that’s part of the reason why I’m in no big hurry to canvass the election," Supervisor Ron Gould said.

Political consultant sounds off on election challenges

Political consultant Stan Barnes says because the state didn't vote as some expected, he believes that is why there is controversy with the election results. While Barnes is not buying into conspiracy theories diminishing the integrity of the election, he says the software claim needs to be looked over. 

"This allegation about the software calculation by the vendor is giving me pause, and what I think needs to happen is we have to have some resolution with that specific item, or our problem grows and is more of a problem in the 2022 election," said Barnes.

Post-Election Accuracy Test held

On Nov. 18, Maricopa County elections officials conducted their Post-Election Logic and Accuracy Test. The test was conducted amid claims of voter fraud in Arizona’s most populated county, and was performed in front of the public, as well as observers.

"So, we do have the Logic and Accuracy Test before and after each election. We also had it for the Presidential Preference Election, same machines, and we had it for the August primary, and every time we did the Logic and Accuracy Test, it did show our equipment is working accurately and properly," said Erika Florez with the Maricopa County Elections Department.

Officials say the test showed the equipment was working properly and accurately. During the test, Arizona Republican Party Chair Kelli Ward spent several hours observing, but records show no one with the Arizona GOP observed the same test before the election.

Continuing Election Coverage


Hearing set for Nov. 18 in Arizona GOP’s election challenge

The party wants the sample measured on a precinct level, rather than among the county’s new vote centers, which let people vote at any location across the county.


Biden transition team says President Trump's refusal to concede is causing problems

President-Elect Joe Biden is meeting with advisors as he moves forward with the transition, but President Trump's refusal to concede the race is slowing down that process.


All ballots counted in Maricopa County; Biden leads Trump in votes

Maricopa County elections officials say efforts in counting all ballots cast in the county are finally complete.